Comfrey Herb Description - Drug Interactions, Dosage and Some of its Useful Properties
Taxonomic Class
Boraginaceae
Common Trade Names
Wise Woman Comfrey Salve. Several combination products are available, including Alticort, Atri-Res, Black Ointment, C&F Formula, Comfrey/Aloe Capsules, Comfrey and Fenugreek, EB5 Footcare Formula, EB5 Toning Formula, #483 Oxox Cell Activator, Goldenseal Salve, H-Complex, Heal-All Salve, Kytta-Plasma f, Kytta-Salbe F, Liniment Virtue, Muco-Plex, Mucoplex, Mustard Salve, Pain-Less Rub, Plantain Salve, Procomfrin, Respa-Herb, Simicort, Super Salve, TANEM, T-ASMA, T-BC, T-BF, Traumaplant, T-SLC, and T-ULe.
Common Forms
Comfrey is available as a blended plant extract also known as “green drink,” homeopathic preparations, a poultice or liniment, a tea (dried leaf and whole root), and a topical cream or ointment and in bulk roots or leaves, capsules, elixir, mucilaginous decoctions, powder, and tincture. Pyrrolizidine alkaloid (PA)-free comfrey preparations are also available. Commercial root preparations are available, but they are not recommended for internal or external use because of their high concentration of PAs. Comfrey is available in combination products in veterinary medicine for topical treatment of muscle strains and ruptures and for oral administration as an antidiarrheal.
Source
An oil is extracted from the leaves and roots of Symphytum officinale, a member of the borage family. Comfrey is a perennial herb that grows in temperate regions, including western Asia, North America, and Australia.
Chemical Components
Comfrey contains a few compounds that show medicinal activity. Mucilage, a mucopolysaccharide of fructose and glucose, is concentrated in the root up to 29%. Allantoin, asparagine, beta-sitosterol, consolicine, consolidine, isobanerenol, lithospermic acid, PAs (up to 0.7% in dried root materials), rosmarinic acid, silicic acid, stigmasterol, symphytocynoglossin, tannins, and triterpenoids (including symphytoxide A) are also found in the plant.
Actions
Mucilage is reported to possess demulcent properties by forming a protective film to soothe irritation and inflammation. Allantoin is claimed to be a cell-growth stimulator, accounting for comfrey’s ability to stirn ulate wound healing and tissue regeneration. Tannin provides the astringent properties and rosmarinic acid imparts anti-inflammatory properties. The triterpenoid symphytoxide A is reported to possess hypotensive activity.
Reported Uses
The application of comfrey is limited to claims for healing wounds. Historically, comfrey was used for several internal ailments, such as ulcers of the bowel, stomach, liver, and gallbladder, but because the alkaloids are converted to toxic metabolites by liver enzymes after being ingested, internal use is no longer recommended.
External application of comfrey products is not considered as dangerous as oral administration. Externally, it is used for bruises and sprains and to promote bone healing.
The anti-inflammatory effects of comfrey were analyzed in 41 patients with musculoskeletal rheumatism. Twenty patients were treated with a PA-free ointment and the remainder received placebo for 4 weeks. Significant improvement was reported with the ointment compared with placebo in patients with epicondylitis and tendovaginitis, but no difference was found in patients with periarthritis .
Dosage
The oil from the leaves and roots can be incorporated in creams and ointments or used in a compress. Ointments and other external preparations are typically made with 5% to 20% comfrey. Comfrey should be applied topically on unbroken skin for less than 10 days or a maximum of 6 weeks per year in amounts at or below a daily dosage of 100 mcg of the unsaturated PAs.
Although comfrey has been used as a tea or taken in capsule form, it is not recommended for internal use because of its toxicity.
Adverse Reactions
CNS: chills, fever.
GI: abdominal pain, diarrhea, hematemesis, poor appetite, vomiting.
Hepatic: hepatotoxicity. exfoliative dermatitis, jaundice.
Other: weight loss, cancer (several animal studies report hepatocellular adenomas and urinary bladder tumors caused by PAs in comfrey death.
Interactions
Eucalyptus: May increase the risk of PA toxicity because of enzyme induction by eucalyptus. Avoid administration with comfrey.
Other PA-containing herbs: May increase risk of toxicity. Herbs that contain PAs include agrimony, alkanna, alpine ragwort, borage, colt’s foot, dusty miller, golden ragwort, goundsel, gravel root, ground’s tongue, hemp, petasties, and tansy ragwort. Avoid administration with comfrey.
Contraindications And Precautions
Internal use of comfrey is contraindicated because of hepatotoxicity. Because PAs are teratogenic and excreted in breast milk of animals, comfrey is contraindicated in pregnant or breast-feeding patients and in young children. It is also contraindicated in patients who are hypersensitive to comfrey and in those with a history of hepatic disease.
Special Considerations
Caution the patient not to use the root for medicinal purposes.
Instruct the patient to apply the mature leaves externally on intact skin for only a limited period; caution him not to use the leaves on open wounds.
Monitor wound appearance and size if the patient is taking comfrey to promote healing.
Assess for signs and symptoms of hepatotoxicity.
Comfrey either alone or in combination has been reported to cause abdominal pain, chills, death, diarrhea, exfoliative dermatitis, fever, hematemesis, jaundice, poor appetite, vomiting, and weight loss .
Alert Several studies report on hepatic veno-occlusive disease caused by PAs in the plant .
Caution the patient against consuming comfrey.
Advise the patient to try commercially available antiseptic ointments and creams before attempting to use comfrey to promote wound healing.
Advise women to avoid using comfrey during pregnancy or when breast-feeding.
Points of Interest
Comfrey has been used since the time of the ancient Greeks and Romans. In the Middle Ages, it was commonly applied as a poultice for treating broken bones, giving rise to the common names of boneset, knitback, and knitbone.
The botanical genus name, Symphytum, originates from the Greek physician Disocorides some 2,000 years ago and is derived from the Greek word sympho, meaning to unite. The common name, comfrey, is derived from the Latin confirmare, which means to heal or unite.
Commentary
Although comfrey has a long history of therapeutic claims for several ailments, it is potentially hepatotoxic and thus should not be consumed. Anecdotal reports and animal studies suggest medicinal benefit for wound healing. Commercially available topical antiseptic agents are probably safer and more effective.
Tagged under:combination products, comfrey herb, comfrey salve, drug interactions, Herbal Medicines, taxonomic class, trade names wise womanShare This